The Federal Court allowed Cambium Networks to add evidence supporting its CNMAESTRO trademark even though it had already defeated a request to expunge the registration.

In Canadian National Railway Company v. Cambium Networks, Ltd., 2026 FC 1192, decided September 24, Justice Nicholas McHaffie held that evidence addressing shortcomings challenged on appeal could be material despite the trademark owner’s earlier success. The order admitted an affidavit but did not decide the appeal itself.

A successful result built on criticized evidence

The Trademarks Opposition Board had maintained Cambium’s registration after finding sufficient use during the three years ending May 16, 2024. The registration covered computer software and two related services for managing wireless networks and devices.

Although the Board accepted the evidence, it identified weaknesses. Canadian National Railway’s appeal attacked proof of which corporate entity used the mark, control over that use and whether use had been established for each registered good and service.

Cambium proposed a second affidavit with more specific evidence of its own use, supported by archived website material, invoices, sales orders and terms of service. The parties agreed to have the evidence motion resolved before the merits hearing.

Materiality was not confined to the losing party

CNR argued that additional evidence could not change a decision already wholly favourable to Cambium. The judge rejected that approach because it would leave a successful party worse off than one that had lost before the Board.

The assessment had to consider the original record, the Board’s findings and the issues on appeal. Evidence capable of answering deficiencies relied on by the appellant could affect the appeal’s outcome and therefore be material.

That did not make every attempt to fill a gap sufficient. New evidence still had to add something significant rather than repeat earlier weaknesses. Here, the affidavit identified Cambium’s own use with greater specificity, both as to the corporate entity and the registered goods and services.

The judge assessed credibility on the affidavit’s face because there had been no cross-examination on this motion. CNR’s concerns about a clearer crop of an earlier photograph did not establish a material credibility problem at that stage.

Transition and delay remained relevant

The interests-of-justice test also required consideration of the delay and possible prejudice. Cambium had filed its original evidence before the April 2025 amendment replaced the former ability to add evidence on appeal without leave.

The affiant cited workload, travel and difficulties assembling evidence. The judge was unpersuaded by attempts to place responsibility on an associate and found no showing that the information had been unavailable. Nevertheless, the explanation was not inherently unreasonable and carried weight in the transitional context.

CNR did not establish prejudice merely because it would have to respond to additional evidence. The court granted leave, while expressly reserving whether the evidence would ultimately answer the appeal grounds.

By agreement, motion costs were fixed at $2,500, payable in the cause of the appeal rather than as an immediate award to Cambium.