The Federal Court allowed PKF Trade Mark Limited to introduce new evidence in its appeal from the expungement of its PKF Design trademark, despite the company’s failure to explain why it had not provided that evidence earlier.

In PKF Trade Mark Limited v. PKF Chambers Inc., 2026 FC 1072, decided August 19, Justice Allyson Whyte Nowak granted leave to file a licensee director’s affidavit. The order addressed admission of evidence, not the merits of the appeal, and awarded no costs.

Evidence aimed at the missing proof of use

The Trademarks Opposition Board had expunged the registration after finding no demonstrated use during the three years ending November 16, 2023. Earlier evidence lacked examples of use within that period; the Canadian examples were hearsay, and some exhibits came later.

The proposed affidavit described the licensee’s Canadian accounting business and said it had issued more than 1,885 branded invoices during the relevant period. It attached 37 examples. For this motion only, PKF Chambers conceded relevance, credibility, admissibility and materiality. Its objections concerned delay and prejudice.

Transition mattered, but counsel’s argument was not evidence

Under subsection 56(5) of the Trademarks Act, the court weighed the interests of justice, including the quality and materiality of the evidence, the circumstances of delay and prejudice to the opposing party.

PKF supplied no evidence explaining the omission. Its lawyer instead relied on the transition from the former provision, which had been treated as allowing new evidence on appeal as of right. The judge gave that argument no evidentiary weight because it could not be tested in cross-examination.

Nevertheless, PKF had presented its case to the Board before the amendment and the decision establishing the new leave test. That context warranted latitude and did not justify an adverse inference from the missing explanation. The judge warned that unexplained delay would take on increasing importance in future cases.

The opposing company’s claimed prejudice consisted of expense and delay in securing its own registrations and extensions in the litigation. Delay was inherent in the statutory process, and litigation expense could be addressed through costs.

No automatic entitlement to another chance

Balancing the factors, the court gave greater weight to relevance and materiality, particularly because non-use proceedings are intended to remove marks genuinely no longer used. It emphasized that there is no fixed formula and any single factor can be decisive.

Despite PKF’s success, the court declined costs because it was largely responsible for the motion’s expense. The respondent’s concession had narrowed the dispute and conserved resources.