
A Saskatchewan bankruptcy registrar has approved a couple’s consumer proposal despite a creditor’s allegations of dishonest disclosure, finding that the administrator investigated the problems and informed creditors of material corrections before the proposal was deemed accepted.
In Ramcharun (Re), 2026 SKKB 145, Registrar Alexander K.V. Shalashniy approved Sewchurn and Kirti Ramcharun’s offer to pay $900 a month for 60 months, a total of $54,000. The August 11 ruling estimated that unsecured creditors would receive about 40 per cent of their claims, compared with approximately 22 per cent in bankruptcy.
The registrar declined to award costs. The decision approved the repayment arrangement; it did not determine that the promised payments had been made or adjudicate a separate claim to recover allegedly preferential transfers.
What the creditor challenged
Objecting creditor Sarvesh Seechurn had made short-term loans to the Ramcharuns and pursued unpaid amounts totalling $9,942.72 in Small Claims Court. That action was stayed when the consumer proposal was filed.
He raised concerns about omitted overseas property, nominal asset values, changing disclosures and possible transfers benefiting family members. He argued that approving the proposal would reward dishonesty rather than assist honest but unfortunate debtors.
An earlier proposal filed by Sewchurn Ramcharun in January 2026 had been withdrawn on the former administrator’s advice after property in Mauritius was omitted and further information was needed. The couple filed the joint proposal with MNP in February. Its initial documents also contained errors, but the registrar distinguished those problems from proof of a pattern of fraud.
Corrections before creditor acceptance
One error came from the administrator’s office: it transposed the total payments as $45,000 instead of $54,000. That produced an estimated unsecured-creditor return of 33.22 per cent instead of 40.16 per cent. A March 4 memorandum gave creditors the correct figures. The proposal itself was formally amended on May 15.
Other corrections concerned two properties in Mauritius. The couple initially reported receiving $22,000 from a 2023 sale, when the correct Canadian-dollar proceeds were $65,037.50. They subsequently corrected that amount and explained how the proceeds had been used.
The administrator had also misunderstood the ownership and value of another property. A March 25 amended report explained that the couple owned it jointly and that its appraised value was $12,432, rather than the earlier $7,375 estimate. It remained listed at a nominal $1 in the statement of affairs, but the administrator included its value in the theoretical bankruptcy comparison and explained the difficulties and costs of realizing it.
The administrator met with the couple, obtained further information, responded directly to Seechurn and provided the appraisal. Those disclosures preceded the proposal’s deemed creditor acceptance around April 13. The later formal amendment did not mean creditors first learned of the payment correction in May.
Fairness to creditors and debtors
Under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the court must refuse a consumer proposal whose terms are unreasonable or unfair to the debtor and creditors. The proposal must also meet statutory requirements governing its duration and payment priorities. A bankruptcy offence, if established, would permit refusal but would not automatically require it. Within those limits, the registrar considered financial rehabilitation, creditors’ recovery and the integrity of the insolvency system.
He found the proposal compliant with the applicable duration and priority requirements and fair to both sides. Creditors were offered a substantially better estimated return than in bankruptcy, while the couple would make meaningful payments toward their debts and obtain a fresh start.
The bankruptcy estimate treated the overseas property as available for realization. If a trustee ultimately found it unrealizable, the actual bankruptcy recovery could be lower still. The comparison therefore did not depend on simply ignoring the property.
The reasons recorded acceptance or acquiescence from 86.14 per cent of creditors. Although Seechurn faced a loss, the registrar emphasized that his position had to be considered alongside the interests of creditors collectively.
Why the disclosure concerns did not defeat approval
Shalashniy stressed that debtors must provide full and accurate disclosure from the outset and administrators must avoid errors affecting confidence in the system. He nevertheless found that some mistakes reflected misunderstandings by the administrator or the couple’s incomplete understanding of what was required, rather than the only possible explanation being deliberate dishonesty.
The summary nature of consumer proposals also mattered. Their investigation is not equivalent to a forensic examination in a well-funded, complex bankruptcy. Assets generally remain with the debtor rather than vesting in a trustee for sale, making some precise valuation disputes less significant to this arrangement.
The registrar did not say every question had been resolved. He noted unanswered issues about the earlier omission, the character of payments to a family member and when an appraisal had been received. He nevertheless regarded the administrator’s investigation and timely disclosure as sufficient in the circumstances. Minor uncertainty about exempt assets did not justify rejecting a proposal offering a better return.
Seechurn’s allegations about preferences were not before the court through a separate statutory application. His argument about a bankruptcy offence also relied on a proposition about Mauritian property law without supporting expert evidence. The registrar addressed whether the disclosure problems defeated approval, rather than conducting a fraud trial.
Refusing approval, he concluded, would likely produce bankruptcies with lower creditor recoveries or another proposal with a similar outcome. The corrected disclosure, investigated before deemed acceptance, allowed the collective repayment arrangement to proceed.
Source: Ramcharun (Re), 2026 SKKB 145.



