The Federal Court of Appeal has set aside two judgments against The Lounge Medical Spa and sent a trademark dispute back for reconsideration, finding that the trial court did not adequately explain its conclusions on liability, disputed evidence, damages or costs.

In Lounge Medical Spa Ltd. v. DermaSpark Products Inc., 2026 FCA 135, released August 6, 2026, the unanimous appeal court allowed the appeals by the spa and Roula Hamdan. It ordered a fresh determination of the summary-trial motion, rather than deciding whether the alleged trademark infringement had been proved.

Two judgments and a corrected damages award

DermaSpark Products and Pollogen had obtained a May 12, 2025 Federal Court judgment finding infringement of trademark rights and damage to goodwill under the Trademarks Act. The order awarded $50,000 in nominal damages for infringement, passing off and dilution of goodwill, followed by a second paragraph also awarding $50,000 in nominal damages.

On July 28, 2025, the Federal Court granted a reconsideration motion and changed the second award to $50,000 in punitive and exemplary damages, acknowledging a preparation error. The spa and Hamdan appealed both judgments.

Justice Sylvie Roussel noted that, apart from minor alterations, the first judgment reproduced the successful parties’ proposed order, including its mistake. Judges may adopt proposed orders or portions of submissions, she explained, but the result must still show independent and impartial consideration of the issues, evidence and law. The appeal turned on inadequate reasons, not a categorical prohibition against using a party’s draft.

Unexplained findings and changing trademark claims

The court applied the ordinary appellate standards: correctness for legal questions, and palpable and overriding error for factual findings and mixed questions. Reasons need not be exhaustive or perfect, but read in context they must explain why the court decided as it did and allow meaningful appellate review.

Passing off was one problem. Although pleaded in the claim, it was not advanced through arguments or a legal test in the summary-trial motion materials. References to cases dealing with passing off did not substitute for submissions on that issue. The appeal court could not understand its inclusion in the damages award without any supporting analysis.

The plaintiffs said they had strategically omitted the argument because they sought nominal damages. The court was not persuaded: the nature and degree of infringement could affect the amount, and the missing explanation remained a problem regardless.

The trademark evidence also shifted between documents. One registration appeared in the motion and judgment but not the statement of claim, request to admit or supporting registration and authorization exhibits. Another appeared in the claim and evidence but disappeared from later pleadings and the judgment. For a further registration, the evidence did not clearly establish DermaSpark’s exclusive authorization to use it.

Those inconsistencies required explanation. The examples offered as evidence also did not make it clear why every registration listed in the judgment had been found infringed.

The disputed machine required closer attention

The spa and Hamdan had not used the prescribed form to respond to a request to admit facts and documents. The Federal Court therefore treated them as having admitted the allegation that their OxyGeneo cosmetic apparatus was counterfeit.

But the record contained conflicting evidence. Within the response period, Hamdan had emailed opposing counsel saying that she had a genuine machine, identifying its serial number and referring to a purchase agreement and supporting documents. A video filed by DermaSpark described features of legitimate machines that could support her position.

The appeal record also included sales and invoice documents whose status before the Federal Court was unclear. The appeal court did not simply accept those documents as properly admitted new evidence. Rather, it said that even the email’s reference to attachments should have prompted clarification of the assertion that the evidence was uncontroversial.

The reasons did not address the conflict or show that it had been considered. The appeal court did not itself decide that the machine was genuine, or that the alleged infringement had not occurred.

Damages, costs and the next step

The court also required an explanation for the nominal damages award. It said comparable cases generally involved awards between $15,000 and $25,000, and the Federal Court needed to justify its conclusion that both plaintiffs were entitled to damages at the higher end of the range. Pollogen had also filed no affidavit evidence supporting a separate damages claim.

The punitive award likewise lacked engagement with the governing principles, including whether compensatory damages were insufficient to achieve punishment and deterrence, and whether the conduct met the demanding threshold for punitive damages. Enhanced costs under Column V of the federal tariff also lacked justification for departing from the usual Column III approach.

Because of the deficient reasons, unclear pleadings and conflicting evidence, the appeal court declined to substitute its own judgment. It set aside the May judgment as amended, separately set aside the July reconsideration judgment, and returned the summary-trial motion to the Federal Court.

That court must decide whether summary trial is suitable or a trial is needed, and adequately explain the chosen course. The appeal court awarded the successful appellants no appeal costs, noting that their failure to formally answer the request to admit or defend the motion had contributed to the situation.

The result leaves the underlying trademark dispute unresolved. Its significance is the requirement for reasoned findings even when a motion is not defended, not a determination that the defendants complied with trademark law.