
The Federal Court awarded Advantage Car & Truck Rentals $80,000 in damages and $30,000 in costs after finding that Orlando Rentco’s competing vehicle-rental branding amounted to passing off in the Greater Toronto Area.
In Advantage Car & Truck Rentals Ltd. v. Orlando Rentco LLC, 2026 FC 933, decided July 13, Justice Angela Furlanetto granted default judgment and a permanent injunction. She also reversed an earlier order separating liability from the calculation of damages so that monetary relief could be determined immediately.
Default did not dispense with proof
Orlando had initially defended the action, but its defence was struck after it failed to appoint replacement counsel as ordered. A later order allowed a properly supported request to reinstate the defence, conditional on paying $25,000 in costs. Those costs were never fully paid, and Orlando remained in default.
That procedural position did not make the allegations automatically true. Advantage still had to establish its claim on a balance of probabilities through clear and convincing evidence.
Long use and actual confusion supported passing off
Advantage had operated in the GTA since 1991 using unregistered ADVANTAGE marks. The evidence established enforceable trademark rights and substantial goodwill through continuous branding, nearly one million rental agreements, advertising and online promotion.
Orlando entered the GTA market in January 2023. The court found its marks nearly identical, with directly overlapping services, customers and advertising channels. Evidence of misdirected calls, emails and enquiries reinforced the likelihood of confusion.
Orlando had previously asserted rights through acquired businesses, but the record did not establish an assignment of Canadian trademark rights or sufficient earlier use. The judge found the evidence inadequate to support its claim to another business’s earlier goodwill.
Although proof of lost sales was thin, potential harm was established through loss of control over reputation and distinctiveness. Confusing online results also affected Advantage’s visibility and marketing costs. Those findings satisfied the required elements of goodwill, misrepresentation and actual or potential damage.
Damages and limits of the order
The court awarded $30,000 in compensatory damages despite the absence of quantified loss, considering the similar services and marks, actual confusion and disregard for Advantage’s rights. It added $50,000 in punitive damages for deliberate wrongful conduct during the proceeding, including breach of the earlier court order, rather than the $100,000 requested.
The injunction covered confusing branding for vehicle rental or leasing services in the GTA, including controlled affiliates. The judgment also required steps within 30 days to remove offending online material and abandon relevant Canadian business-name registrations, with proof of those steps.
The judge declined to require withdrawal of trademark applications, leaving the disputed applications and opposition proceedings to the Registrar. A separate injunction aimed at anticipated future infringement was unnecessary because the permanent order already covered future affiliates.
The judgment included interest and $30,000 in all-inclusive costs. It did not establish that the ordered payments or removal steps had subsequently been completed.



