A Manitoba estate was permitted to sell a home to pay its debts even though a surviving partner’s disputed homestead rights had not yet been resolved. The court protected that unresolved interest by directing that sale proceeds be held pending a further decision.

In Burbank v. Lelyk, 2026 MBKB 83, delivered June 17, Justice Woolley separated two questions: whether the surviving partner retained homestead rights, and whether those rights prevented an estate sale.

The ruling allowed the sale but did not determine that Wyman Lelyk had lost his claimed rights. That issue, and their value if they survived, was referred to an associate judge.

Relationship dispute could not be resolved on affidavits

Lelyk and Sheila Holt had lived together for years in an unregistered common-law relationship. Holt bought the Winnipeg property in 2009. Her will directed that the net sale proceeds be divided equally between Lelyk and her daughter.

After Holt’s death in January 2024, the estate sought to sell the property. Lelyk remained there and claimed a surviving common-law partner’s entitlement to a life estate under the Homesteads Act.

The estate argued that the relationship had ended years earlier, despite continued residence under the same roof. It relied on affidavit evidence and changes to Holt’s tax and insurance records. Lelyk disputed a separation and pointed to continued household contributions, support and documents treating them as a couple.

The court explained that sharing a residence does not necessarily mean a couple is still living together as partners. An intention to separate can be held by one person, but must be objectively shown to have been communicated and acted upon.

The evidence did not permit a reliable finding. Letters supporting Lelyk lacked context and had not been tested. The estate’s evidence also raised hearsay concerns and inconsistencies about when separation allegedly occurred. No affidavit witnesses had been cross-examined, leaving the court unable to resolve important credibility disputes.

Possible homestead rights did not stop the sale

The Law of Property Act supplied a separate route. Relying on Manitoba appeal authority, Woolley held that an estate sale could be ordered without first deciding whether the partners had separated.

A surviving partner’s homestead entitlement remains subject to estate creditors’ claims. Where there is no other source of funds, the home can be sold to meet those obligations.

The estate had a legitimate debt-payment purpose. There was no evidence of an improper application or wrongdoing in the creation of the disputed debt. Lelyk would face the hardship of finding another home, but that alone did not establish unusual circumstances sufficient to defeat the estate’s right to a sale.

Any surviving homestead interest nevertheless had to be accounted for in the proceeds. Permission to sell was not permission to distribute the money as though that claim did not exist.

Proceeds held while rights are determined

The order granted the estate vacant possession and required Lelyk to arrange removal of his belongings within 14 days of the order. An associate judge was to direct the sale and determine whether his homestead rights should be terminated and, if not, their value.

Except for costs directly related to the sale, proceeds were to remain in court until a final order on those rights. The judgment does not establish that a sale or subsequent rights determination has since occurred.

Woolley refused the estate’s request for solicitor-client costs. Other costs could be addressed later if the parties could not agree.