Therme Development lost its challenge to the removal of some services from four trademark registrations, even though the Federal Court of Appeal found an error in how the lower court assessed two marks combining words and designs.

In Therme Development (CY) Ltd. v. Nordik Spa Village Chelsea Inc., 2026 FCA 85, Justice George Locke, writing for a unanimous panel, corrected that analysis but reached the same result. The May 5 judgment dismissed the appeal with costs.

The dispute concerned THERME, THERME GROUP and two composite marks identified as THERME WOMAN and THERME WOMAN’S HEAD. Nordik had obtained a Federal Court order striking certain listed services from the registrations. The case did not erase every registration or decide that all uses of the branding were prohibited.

The whole mark must be considered first

One issue was whether the two composite marks, when sounded, clearly described certain services in French. Therme argued that their large, detailed designs dominated the marks, rather than the word THERME.

The appeal court agreed that the Federal Court had approached the question incorrectly. It had treated the words as dominant because the designs could not be spoken. That put the second step of the legal test before the first.

A court must first assess the consumer’s initial visual impression of the entire mark and decide whether its words dominate. Relevant considerations include the relative size of the words and design, lettering, colour, layout and the design’s inherent distinctiveness. Only after finding the words dominant does the court ask whether the mark is clearly descriptive when sounded.

The panel did not send the issue back. Therme’s counsel agreed that the appeal court could decide it on the available record. Although the designs were larger and more complex, Justice Locke found that an ordinary prospective consumer would have the word THERME foremost in mind. Applying the proper approach therefore left the finding of clear descriptiveness intact for the services in question.

A misleading description is a separate problem

Therme also challenged findings that THERME and the two composite marks were deceptively misdescriptive in French for other services. It argued that a mark could not be misleadingly descriptive if it had not first been found descriptive of those services.

The court rejected that reasoning. A mark must describe something before it can misdescribe, but it need not accurately describe the very services for which registration is sought. The prohibition addresses a mark that could mislead consumers about the character or quality of those services.

Here, the possibility that a health spa resort or wellness centre might not provide thermal baths supported, rather than defeated, the concern about misleading description. The lower court could apply common sense from the ordinary consumer’s perspective. The appeal court found no legal error or sufficiently serious factual error warranting intervention.

It also rejected an alleged mismatch between the lower court’s reasons and order. Read in context, the reasoning about THERME applied to both composite marks as well.

French descriptiveness and English confusion can coexist

Therme argued that it was contradictory to treat THERME as descriptive while also finding THERME and THERME GROUP confusing with Nordik’s THERMËA marks. The panel explained that the conclusions concerned different linguistic perspectives: the French pronunciation corresponded to the word for thermal baths, while the confusion finding rested on the words’ English pronunciation.

The lower court’s pronunciation and distinctiveness findings were factual. Arguments about the shared THERM prefix and different word endings did not demonstrate a palpable and overriding error, the demanding standard for overturning those findings.

The panel also upheld exclusion of a linguist’s affidavit as unnecessary to assess the average consumer’s reaction in this case. It did not establish a rule excluding expert evidence from every trademark dispute or every case involving invented words.

The appeal was dismissed with costs, without a dollar amount specified in these reasons. The court also updated Nordik’s name in the style of cause.

Therme subsequently sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. The public docket for file 42463 records an August 4 application and September response and reply filings. No decision on leave appeared in the docket checked for this report. An application for leave is not permission to appeal.