
The Federal Court of Appeal has dismissed McCain Foods Limited’s challenge to a ruling that a potato-processing technology used by its French fry competitors did not infringe its patent, finding no reversible error in the trial court’s interpretation of the claimed electric field.
In McCain Foods Limited v. J.R. Simplot Company, 2026 FCA 71, the court upheld the construction of Canadian Patent No. 2,412,841 adopted in 2025 FC 1078. The April 14 decision awarded the respondents the parties’ agreed all-inclusive appeal costs of $30,000.
A dispute over the scope of the claimed process
The patent concerned applying an electric field to vegetables or fruit before cooking, making them easier to cut without first heating them. McCain and the Simplot companies produce and sell frozen French fries.
The Federal Court found that a skilled food-process engineer would understand the electric field in claim 1 to fall within a range of approximately two to 200 volts per centimetre. Simplot’s pulsed-electric-field systems operated at 1,000 volts per centimetre or more. On that construction, those systems did not infringe the patent during its lifetime.
The trial court also made alternative findings: if the claims extended to Simplot’s technology, they would be broader than the invention made or contemplated and lack demonstrated or soundly predicted utility. McCain challenged both the interpretation of the claims and the resulting validity analysis.
Expert evidence shaped the standard of review
Although interpreting a patent claim is theoretically a question of law, the appeal court explained that claims must be understood from the perspective of the skilled reader. Where that interpretation depends on evaluating expert evidence about how that reader would understand particular terms, the trial court receives deference.
Here, the Federal Court had considered competing expert views in detail. McCain therefore needed to establish a palpable and overriding error, rather than persuade the appellate judges to select their own preferred interpretation.
McCain argued that the patent itself contained no numerical limit and that the trial court had imposed an unjustifiably narrow boundary. The appeal court found that the range flowed from an extensive analysis of the relevant technical knowledge, the claims’ wording, the absence of a reference to pulses in the claims and the specification as a whole.
The judges also rejected the argument that the Federal Court improperly confined the invention to the examples described in the patent. Preferred embodiments do not define the outer limit of a claim, but they remain relevant to its purposive interpretation.
References in the disclosure to pulsed fields and sugar extraction did not require McCain’s proposed construction. The Federal Court had addressed those passages and was entitled, on the expert evidence, to read them in context rather than as isolated connections establishing a broader claim.
Validity arguments left unaddressed on appeal
The court found no reviewable error in the construction that excluded Simplot’s systems. That conclusion resolved the appeal, so the appellate judges did not need to decide McCain’s arguments about validity. The decision therefore should not be read as a separate appellate analysis affirming every alternative invalidity ground.



