Newfoundland and Labrador planning adjudicator Garreth McGrath dismissed David Nippard’s accessory-building appeal against Paradise on March 25, 2026. See the Appeal 15-006-094-003.

To meet the aggregate 150-square-metre cap for accessory buildings, Nippard needed to reduce the existing building’s floor area by 9.7 square metres. He installed a cantilevered section and argued that its fixed end became the exterior wall, excluding the space underneath from the calculation.

The regulations measured floor area to the outside face of exterior walls. At the hearing, Nippard acknowledged that an opening beneath the cantilever had been left for inspection and later closed.

McGrath found that closing it re-established the exterior wall at its former location. The proposed reduction therefore failed on the actual construction, without deciding whether an open cantilever arrangement would otherwise have qualified.

The adjudicator rejected the town’s jurisdictional objection: determining whether conditions for approval had been met concerned an application to undertake development and was appealable.

The town’s refusal was confirmed. The decision did not approve the second building.