
The Federal Court of Appeal has set aside two copyright declarations obtained by the Attorney General after Blacklock’s Reporter discontinued its infringement action against Parks Canada, finding that the declarations served no practical purpose in resolving a live dispute.
In 1395804 Ontario Ltd. (Blacklock’s Reporter) v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FCA 56, the court allowed the publisher’s appeal and dismissed the Attorney General’s summary-judgment motion for the declarations. The March 19 ruling does not decide the wider questions of whether sharing access credentials is fair dealing or whether the publisher’s paywall is a technological protection measure.
Counterclaim outlasted the infringement action
Blacklock’s had alleged that Parks Canada improperly used a paid subscription to access, read and distribute articles. The publisher discontinued that action in July 2020. The Attorney General had served an amended defence and counterclaim the previous day, seeking 10 declarations concerning subscription terms, article use and technological protection measures.
The Attorney General pursued summary judgment partly on the basis that it could help resolve other disputes involving federal departments. The Federal Court ultimately granted only two declarations in 2024 FC 829.
One described Parks Canada’s use of a subscription password in the particular circumstances as fair dealing. The other stated, conditionally, that lawful acquisition and use of a password did not circumvent a technological protection measure if the password otherwise qualified as one.
Practical utility requires a live controversy
The appeal court applied the Supreme Court’s test requiring a declaration to have practical utility by settling a live controversy between the parties. The Federal Court had not adequately addressed that requirement.
The first declaration depended on findings about the particular subscription Parks Canada purchased and the circumstances of its use. With the infringement action discontinued, re-examining the conflicting evidence about those matters would not resolve a live controversy. The appeal court also questioned how such fact-specific findings could usefully determine another department’s different subscription dispute.
The second declaration did not determine whether a password was itself a technological protection measure. It assumed lawful acquisition and use and addressed the consequence if a password otherwise met the statutory definition. The court regarded that qualified proposition as too generic to resolve a live dispute between these parties.
Paywall issue was outside the judgment under appeal
Blacklock’s challenged a statement in the Federal Court’s reasons that its paywall was not the technological protection measure at issue. The appeal court stressed that an appeal is taken from the judgment, not every statement in the reasons.
Neither declaration in the judgment decided that the paywall was not a protection measure. After discontinuance, the remaining pleadings were the Attorney General’s counterclaim, whose requested declarations focused on password sharing and the particular subscription circumstances. They did not put the separate paywall question before the court.
The appeal court therefore treated the Federal Court’s paywall comment as unnecessary to the disposition. It expressly neither endorsed nor criticized that comment. Setting aside the declarations was not an appellate ruling that Parks Canada infringed copyright, nor approval of unrestricted password or article sharing.
Costs left for agreement or submissions
The court gave the parties an opportunity to agree on costs payable by the Attorney General to Blacklock’s for the Federal Court and appeal proceedings, with a written-submissions schedule if agreement proved impossible. The judgment did not fix an amount.
The result turns on the limits of declaratory relief after the underlying action ended. It leaves the substantive copyright questions to be resolved in a proceeding and evidentiary record that properly raise them.



