
The Supreme Court of Canada upheld orders requiring the return of millions of dollars diverted from two construction companies through false invoices, ruling that a company’s ability to pay its creditors does not defeat a claim based on an intent to defraud them.
In Aquino v. Bondfield Construction Co., a unanimous seven-judge court also held that the fraudulent intent of a company’s directing mind can be attributed to the company for the purpose of recovering transfers at undervalue, even when the fraud harmed the company and brought it no benefit.
Justice Mahmud Jamal’s October 11, 2024 reasons dismissed the appeal with costs. The decision preserves a creditor-protection remedy against asset stripping while explaining why the rules for attributing a person’s conduct to a corporation must fit the particular law being applied.
False invoices drained two companies
John Aquino was president and a directing mind of Bondfield Construction Company Limited and its affiliate, 1033803 Ontario Inc., known as Forma-Con. After Bondfield entered restructuring proceedings in April 2019 and Forma-Con became bankrupt that December, their court-appointed monitor and bankruptcy trustee investigated payments to suppliers.
The investigations uncovered a scheme in which Aquino and others created invoices for services never provided. The companies paid promptly, often within days, at the direction of Aquino or other participants. In the five years before the insolvency proceedings, Bondfield paid more than $21.8 million and Forma-Con more than $11.3 million on false invoices.
Ernst & Young, Bondfield’s monitor, and KSV, Forma-Con’s trustee, sought recovery under section 96 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. The Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act makes that remedy available in restructuring proceedings as well. The application judge ordered repayment, and the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the result.
The Supreme Court appeal raised two distinct objections: whether the companies had the necessary intent to defraud, defeat or delay creditors, and whether Aquino’s fraudulent intent could legally count as the companies’ intent when he was stealing from them.
Solvency did not answer the fraud claim
A transfer at undervalue involves a debtor giving away property or services for no consideration, or for consideration conspicuously below fair market value. Section 96 sets different recovery conditions depending on the relationship between the parties and when the transfer occurred.
This case concerned non-arm’s-length transfers made more than one year but less than five years before the initial bankruptcy event. For that category, the statute permits recovery where the debtor was insolvent at the time or became insolvent because of the transfer, or where the debtor intended to defraud, defeat or delay a creditor. Insolvency and fraudulent intent are alternative routes, rather than cumulative requirements.
The appellants argued that the companies could pay their creditors when the payments were made. They challenged the finding of fraudulent intent on the basis that creditors were not then endangered by insolvency.
The court rejected the proposition that solvency prevents such a finding. Financial condition is relevant evidence, but Parliament did not make insolvency a prerequisite to the fraudulent-intent branch of the provision. Requiring it would erase the distinction Parliament drew.
Intent must be assessed from all the circumstances at the time of the transfer, without hindsight. Courts may infer it from recognized indicators of fraud. Here, those included payments to non-arm’s-length parties, no services in return, secrecy and false documentation, and unusual haste in paying invoices. The companies also had significant long-term and off-balance-sheet liabilities, as well as potential liabilities as guarantors for other companies.
The application judge’s finding of intent was supported by the evidence. The deceptive recordkeeping itself made the companies’ precise financial position difficult to establish. The participants could not use the unreliability of records produced through their scheme to undo the finding against them.
A company harmed by fraud can still have the relevant intent
The second issue arose because corporations act through people. Corporate attribution determines when an individual’s acts and state of mind are treated as those of the corporation.
Ordinarily, attribution requires a directing mind acting within the sector of corporate operations assigned to that person. The traditional framework also contains exceptions where the person acts entirely in fraud of the corporation or where the conduct neither aims to benefit nor benefits it. Courts have discretion to decline attribution where it would be contrary to the public interest.
The appellants relied on the fraud and absence-of-benefit exceptions: Aquino was taking company money, not advancing the companies’ interests.
Jamal explained that attribution is not a rigid formula applied identically to every legal question. Its operation must reflect the context and purpose of the rule under which corporate responsibility is being considered. That does not authorize an unrestricted, case-by-case choice of whatever outcome a judge prefers.
For section 96, applying the exceptions would undermine the remedy. Asset stripping commonly harms the debtor corporation while benefiting the person directing the scheme. Treating that harm as a reason to refuse attribution would obstruct recovery for creditors in the very circumstances the provision addresses.
The court therefore held that the fraud and absence-of-benefit exceptions do not apply in this statutory context. The required connection remains: the wrongdoer must be a directing mind, and the conduct must fall within the assigned sector of corporate operations. Aquino’s responsibility for supplier relationships brought the payments within that sector.
The court also corrected two aspects of the appeal court’s reasoning. A company in restructuring is not necessarily reduced to a pool of assets awaiting liquidation; rehabilitation remains possible. Nor does every recovery dispute simply pit fraudsters against creditors: recipients of challenged transfers may be innocent. The statutory purpose, rather than either generalization, supported attribution here.
Recovery orders and later enforcement are separate
The ruling affirmed the repayment result; it did not establish that creditors had collected the money.
In a later proceeding, the Ontario Court of Appeal on February 25, 2026 dismissed Aquino’s appeal from orders placing him personally in bankruptcy and continuing an asset-freezing injunction. Its reasons in Aquino (Re), 2026 ONCA 132 record that he had no present ability to pay the judgment debts when the bankruptcy application was decided. That later enforcement decision is distinct from the Supreme Court’s 2024 ruling on liability.
Source: Supreme Court of Canada, Aquino v. Bondfield Construction Co., 2024 SCC 31.



